Monday, November 16, 2026
1957 American murderer and bodysnatcher Ed Gein killed his last victim
1961 JFK decided to increase military aid to South Vietnam without committing US combat troops
1969 The 1968 Mỹ Lai massacre of between 347 and 504 unarmed South Vietnamese civilians by US soldiers was first reported
1969 The British House of Commons voted 343-185 to abolish the death penalty
1989 Six Jesuit priests were assassinated by the Salvadoran army - one of the most notorious acts of the Salvadoran civil war
2000 Bill Clinton became the first U.S. President to visit Vietnam since the end of the Vietnam War
In bed at 8:35, up at 4:10; 0430 203.2 115/71/64 109; 31/25/52/30, mostly sunny morning, mostly cloudy afternoon.
Morning meds at 7:40 a.m. Entresto at 7:30 a.m. and p.m.
British abolition of the death penalty. It took Britain, a historically and notoriously cruel empire (Cruel Britannia, one book by Ian Cohain, another by Nick Cohen) until 1969 to abolish the death penalty. In the United States, 27 states, the federal government, and the military justice system retain the death penalty as a possible sentence for certain crimes. California, Ohio, Oregon, and Pennsylvania have executive moratoriums or pauses on executions, although their laws continue to authorize the death penalty. Indeed, according to the Death Penalty Information Center, 33 states have either abolished capital punishment or gone at least ten years without an execution. Wisconsin, happily, abolished capital punishment in 1853, making it the first state to abolish it permanently for all crimes.
As far back as I can remember, I have been opposed to capital punishment. Even for Hitler, Stalin, Ted Bundy, or Jeffrey Dahmer? Yes. I won't go into the arguments pro and con, except to say that I don't think any jurisdiction should, in the name of its citizens, engage in cold-blooded homicide. I suppose I could imagine some circumstances in which, under the principle of 'double effect,' I could justify it, but never simply as punishment or retribution for wrongdoing, even egregious wrongdoing. I don't believe any jurisdiction has a right to authorize one human being to throw the switch, or pull the trigger, or by any means to take the life of another human being, even a thoroughly wicked one.The Catholic Church's position on capital punishment has undergone one of the most striking changes in its moral teaching over the past two thousand years. For most of its history, the Church accepted the right of legitimate civil authorities to execute criminals. Today, it teaches that the death penalty is inadmissible and calls for its abolition throughout the world. The decisive change occurred under Pope Francis in 2018, but it was preceded by a gradual movement away from capital punishment, particularly during the twentieth century.
Not surprisingly, I suppose, there is a substantial theological controversy about whether this represents a legitimate development of doctrine or a reversal of what the Church had taught for centuries. The Church has long been hung up on its claim that all its official actions are guided by the Holy Ghost, that it speaks and teaches with divine authority, that it possesses what it grandly calls Magisterium, or authority. If it is guided by God, to whom it claims to have a pipeline, especially through the Pope, how could it have taught - and practiced itself - that capital punishment is not sinful, and then do an about-face and teach that it is sinful? How can there be any changes in the Church's doctrines and teachings if earlier teachings were somehow guided by the Holy Ghost? This conundrum became a huge problem when the Church had to reconsider its teaching on birth control after the advent of the birth control pill. I wrote about it in my memoir:
The Catholic Church also revealed its feet of clay during 1968. Cardinal Spellman was spouting his murderous nonsense about ‘a war for civilization’ without restraint by the Vatican and Catholics were generally as resistant as any other group to much of the civil rights demands. The big difference maker in terms of authority however had nothing to do with war and peace or civil rights, but with sex, Paul VI’s encyclical banning contraception, including birth control pills. In 1963, John XXIII had established a commission to study population and birth control issues. Paul VI appointed 15 cardinals and bishops and 64 lay experts to the commission. The commission provided a report in 1966 saying contraception was not intrinsically evil. The vote among the clergy was 9 to 6; the lay commission vote was 60 to 4. One of the dissenters was Karol Wojtyla, later John Paul II. The dissenters feared that a change in the Church’s position would call into question the pope’s teaching authority. The report was leaked to the press in 1967 and there was a very favorable reaction among modern Catholics, who expected the pope to adopt the commission’s recommendation. Instead, Paul VI rejected the recommendation and adopted the dissenting position, undoubtedly fearing that any change in the Church’s position would weaken the claim to papal authority. What happened, of course, was precisely what Paul and the Vatican conservatives wanted to avoid: widespread rejection of the Church’s teaching authority, especially by American and Western European Catholics. The pope and his conservative curial apparatchiks were seen as, at best. mired in medievalism, and, at worst, more concerned about the power of the shepherds than in the welfare of the flock.
I included Wojtyla's dissent in a footnote. It's precious.
Paul VI fell for that happy horseshit. Can it be any wonder that so many former Catholics, like me, feel so much anger against those guys in their fancy mitres and chasubles and fancy talk? That so many women, especially, have such anger? My mother was affected by this happy horseshit. She stayed away from church for years after WWII ended, because she used birth control to avoid having another child when my Dad came back from the war emotionally wrecked, unemployed and largely unemployable. She struggled to keep our little family going on her paltry earnings from tips she earned as a waitress. There were days when our meals consisted of bread and lunch meat bought "on the cuff" and Mr. and Mrs. Kelly's mom-and-pop grocery store down the street from our 3 room basement apartment, and, all that time, her Church was telling her that, as Cardinal Wyjtyla put it, she was "under pain of eternal damnation." I feel the anger well up in me again as I write these words and reflect on those days after the war.“If it should be declared that contraception is not evil in itself, then we should have to concede frankly that the Holy Spirit had been on the side of the Protestant churches in 1930 (when the encyclical Casti Connubi was promulgated) and in 1951 (Pius XII’s address delivered before the Society of Hematologists in the year the pope died).
“It should likewise have to be admitted that for a half a century the Spirit failed to protect Pius XI, Pius XII, and a large part of the Catholic hierarchy from a very serious error. This would mean that the leaders of the Church, acting with extreme imprudence, had condemned thousands of innocent human acts, forbidding, under pain of eternal damnation, a practice which would now be sanctioned. The fact can neither be denied nor ignored that these same acts would now he declared licit on the grounds of principles cited by the Protestants, which popes and bishops have either condemned or at least not approved” [Emphasis added by me.]
From my point of view, the United States’ position on the war in Vietnam and the Church’s position on contraception flowed from the same source. Johnson and his advisors and Paul VI and his advisors were more concerned with institutional credibility than with the lives of their “subjects.” Not losing face, nationally and personally, was more important to Johnson than the lives of the thousands of Americans and Vietnamese who were suffering in the war. Better that thousands should die or be horribly wounded than that the United States be seen for what it inevitably was in Vietnam, an arrogant and feckless loser. Nixon and Kissinger, of course, had the same value system at work as they kept the war going until 1973 and indeed they were more immoral and corrupt than Johnson. Kissinger had been privy to the 1968 peace negotiations in Paris and fed information to the Nixon election campaign that it looked like the negotiators were going to arrive at a settlement before the election. Nixon communicated with South Vietnamese President, Thieu, advising him to boycott the peace conference because ‘we are going to win.’ Thieu refused to attend, the efforts to end the war came to naught and three days later, Nixon narrowly defeated Hubert Humphrey by less than 1% of the popular vote. Between 1969 and 1973, tens of thousands of Americans would be killed in the war and hundreds of thousands of Vietnamese. To Nixon and Kissinger and to millions of other Americans, American “honor” was more important than American lives, and infinitely more important than Vietnamese lives. For Paul VI, the Church’s magisterium was more important than the lives of millions of Catholics affected by the Church’s teaching on birth control. Better that Catholics, especially women, should face the choice between (1) bearing children they did not want or could not care for, or (2) the fear of eternal damnation (“Do you know how long eternity is, boys and girls?”) than that the authority of the celibate boys in brocades and funny hats be questioned.
But - back to the Church's shifty and shifting position on the morality of capital punishment. My position is better late than never, better right than wrong. As far as the Church's magisterium, Paul VI kissed that off when he fell for Wojtyla's lines about the Holy Ghost and not admitting that the Protestants were right and the Church had been wrong. Amen and amen.
LTMW at an active morning at our feeding station. Three white-tailed deer showed up before dawn and nibbled at the seeds on the ground, but didn't try to reach the suspended tray feeder where yesterday's lone buck found his treasure trove of seeds. I notice that the neighborhood mourning doves are increasingly showing up in a flock of 10 or 12 birds, unlike this summer when they appeared more in ones and twos. I suppose this is related to their nesting habits.A good and sometimes great teacher is unique. They are special, as we all should know. Often, that teacher can be from very early times at school. They are your guide, they inspire, they become a bit of a friend. If you're lucky, they may be your mentor for life. A good teacher is just that: completely worthy, much better than most, and someone always in your hall of fame. When we recall our lives, more often than not a wonderful teacher comes alive again in that distant classroom. Full of life and ready to inspire, unfailingly.
I had two good and great teachers in my educational life. The first, Brother Coogan, taught Class 4A, the "brainy" senior class at Leo High School, college preppers, 4 years of Latin, etc. Coogan taught the 4th-year English Literature class, a regular 45 or 50 minute class, but he made the entire class show up for an additional English class at 8 a.m. each morning to review just about everything we had ever been taught in English classes: diagramming sentences, vocabulary, etymology, syntax, spelling - all the very basics. He also gave us research and writing assignments that required us to visit the great Newberry Library downtown, and the libraries at the University of Chicago. He took us, and our minds, out of high school and into the broader intellectual world, and the grubby world. The elegant Newberry Library is across the street from Chicago's "Bughouse Square" where any wannabe orator could stand on the park benches and hold forth to whatever audience he could attract. Its next-door neighbors to the west were the North Clark Street dive bars of ill repute. The University of Chicago was in toney Hyde Park, but it was surrounded by Chicago's southside ghettos and notorious Robert Taylor "projects" or public housing. We took streetcars, buses, and ELs to get to those citadels of learning. I've long believed that Brother Coogan made an enormous difference in my life.
The other great teacher would cause my law school classmates to raise their eyebrows, I suspect. It was Ray J. Aiken, our Civil Procedure and Bills and Notes professor. Once I was on the faculty, I also shared an office suite with him, one the students called the Military-Industrial Complex, but that's another story. And I worked as his Assistant University Legal Counsel when he was legal counsel to the university's leadership team. It wasn't until I was on the faculty with him, and working with him in the university counsel's office, that I came to love, and almost revere him. He was an odd duck. He was histrionic, not only in the classroom, but even in his office. He was also a bit of a headstrong bully in arguing his points of contention. He had been a CYO Golden Gloves boxer at Washington High School in his youth, and that may have contributed to his intellectual pugnacity, or perhaps it was his inherent pugnacity that led him into boxing. In any event, he could turn people off with his histrionic, pugnacious style. I loved him, however, not because of that off-putting style, but because of his underlying characteristics that I came fully to appreciate after working with him for a few years and getting to know him personally, almost intimately. He was a generous, outgoing, free-giving soul. He must have known, I suspect, that many of those around him made fun of him and his histrionic, bulldog style, but he never altered himself to be someone other than who he was. He gave his all in whatever work he was performing, or task he was engaged in: teaching 100 law students in a classroom, counseling an individual student or younger faculty colleague in his office, leading the law school chorus back in the day when it existed, or hosting the Bar-B-Q at his home in Delafied for the entire graduating class after they had been sworn in to the bar at the supreme court.. He believed his work was important, no matter what he was doing, important to him and to the person at whom his efforts were directed. He was intensely focused and committed.
Ray's wife Patricia was a lovely person, a Batik artist, but she left Ray and ran away with another artist, to India, I think. Her artistic personality was as different from Ray's as one could imagine. Her leaving him after 25 or 30 years of marriage wasn't entirely shocking to those of us who knew both of them, but it was devastating for Ray. I remember having dinner with him and another young law professor, Pat Hetrick, one night after Patricia had left their home. Hetrick left early, but I stayed and sipped whiskey with Ray for hours. It was the first time I had seen him so chastened and vulnerable. It was about 50 years ago, but I remember it still, and still feel the sadness of that long night with him. The other time I saw him vulnerable was after he had retired, remarried, and come down with Alzheimer's. We were at some law school function that his second wife brought him to, and Ray came up to me and introduced himself to me, twice. He hadn't recognized me. At his memorial gathering at the law school, I gave a eulogy for him. I mentioned that at his funeral, the beautiful hymn Precious Lord, was sung, with the lyrics: Precious Lord, take my hand / Lead me on, let me stand / I'm tired, I'm weak, I'm worn / Through the storm, through the night / Lead me on to the light / Take my hand, precious Lord / Lead me home. I remarked how hard it was to remember Ray as tired, or weak, or worn, having known him in his heyday at the law school, so strong, so energetic, and so feisty. Others spoke at his memorial gathering, too, of his love of the law, his love of teaching, and suchlike, but I had the sense that none of them knew Ray as intimately as I had. He was my second good and great teacher, my mentor, my friend, and I miss him to this day.
Trump will meet with Putin and Xi in China on this trip. Does anybody really think that anything good for America (or the world) will come out of that meeting? Of the three of them, does anyone really think that Trump is the smartest? the most experienced? the most able to protect his country's interests? Will Trump agree to divvying up the world: the Western Hemisphere to the US, Europe to Putin, and East Asia to Xi? My hunch is that nothing good will come out of this meeting, or worse, Xi and Putin will take Trump to the cleaners.



















